Today's Date:
Contact Us
About Us
Family Ministries
Social Ministries
Official Documents
Documents on the CFC Crisis
Downloads on the CFC Crisis
Recognition by the Clergy
Support from the Community
Audio Tracks Downloads
Sharings & Testimonies
Schedule of Events
Treasury of Prayers
Photo Gallery
Site Map
"The Signs of the Times"

The secular assault against the Catholic Church continues. There has been the media's overemphasis on sexual abuses in the Catholic Church, while keeping quiet over sexual abuses in the Protestant churches (which are greater in frequency) and in secular educational institutions (which are much greater in frequency). There has been the personal attacks on the pope, trying to pin him down on these clerical sexual abuses. Now here is a court case against the Vatican, which is a sovereign state.

The anti-life, anti-family, homosexualist forces are going all out in trying to bring down the one institution that stands in the way of their diabolical agenda. At the forefront of this are the US and Western nations, backed by secular media. Though the gates of hell cannot prevail against the body of Christ on earth, the enemy can cause great confusion and even a weakening of the body.

But this is a time of purification for the Church, her own Job experience. And so it is a blessed time. The attacks of the enemy have awakened many bishops and ordinary Catholic laypeople. It is a time to rise in defense of the Church, and to really prepare for the final battle.

US Supreme Court Denies Vatican Appeal

Sends Oregon Abuse Case Back to District Courts

WASHINGTON, D.C., JUNE 30, 2010 ( The U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear an appeal from the Vatican that would contest the decision of the lower courts in Oregon to allow the Holy See to be sued for transferring a known sex offender from Ireland to Chicago to Oregon.

The court issued its decision Monday, which in effect allows the lawsuit John V. Doe v. Holy See to move forward in the Oregon courts, where it was initially filed.

The plaintiff, who says a priest of the Servants of Mary, Father Andrew Ronan, molested him in the 1960s, accuses the Vatican of negligence in dealing with the known sexual abuser. The priest had been found guilty of abusing boys in Ireland and Chicago before he was moved Portland.

Jeff Anderson, the attorney for John V. Doe, said on Monday that "the claims against the Holy See included vicarious liability for the acts of its instrumentalities and domestic corporations, respondeat superior for the actions of Ronan as an alleged employee of the Holy See, and direct liability based on the Holy See’s own negligence in retention and supervision of Ronan, and its failure to warn of his harmful propensities."

The Holy See's attorney in the case, Jeffrey Lena, invoked sovereign immunity in an attempt to get the lawsuit dismissed, but both the district court and the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals denied the motion, based on exceptions in the law. The court said that if Father Ronan could be considered an employee of the Vatican, then it would be ultimately responsible for his actions.

Lena petitioned the Supreme Court to hear an appeal, but that petition was denied Monday.


In comments to the National Catholic Register, Lena said that while the decision is disappointing, it's not a decision against the Holy See's case.

"It would have been helpful had the Supreme Court accepted the case," he told the newspaper, "but the issue before the court was narrow, relating only to the meaning of the term 'scope of employment.' The decision of the court not to take the case is not a reflection of a lack of merit. In fact, as is well known, the United States agrees with the Holy See on the underlying legal issue."

He said the next step is to return to the district court in Oregon, and prove that Father Ronan was not an employee of the Vatican, "and that, therefore, the district court does not have jurisdiction over the case."

"The Holy See did not pay the salary of the priest or provide his benefits or exercise day-to-day control over him," Lena explained, "or have any other connection with him indicating the presence of an employment relationship."

"For to me to live is Christ, and to die is gain." (Phil 1:21)
Copyright 2008 Couples for Christ Foundation, Inc.
Apartelle 12, Star Mall, Edsa corner Shaw Blvd.
Mandaluyong City 1550, Philippines
Tel. Nos. +63(2) 718-2213 * Fax No. +63(2) 718-2213
CFC-FFL Webmaster